The Female Church Leaders Podcast
The Female Church Leaders Podcast with Kadi Cole offers practical tools and biblical insight for women leading in the local church. Each week, Kadi shares real stories, leadership strategies, and spiritual encouragement to help you grow in confidence, sharpen your skills, and lead with clarity. Whether you’re on staff, volunteering, building a ministry, or stepping into new levels of leadership, you’ll find wisdom, hope, and a community of female church leaders who get it - and are cheering you on!
The Female Church Leaders Podcast
FCLP 41 | How to Fire a Volunteer
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this thoughtful leadership episode of the Female Church Leaders Podcast, Kadi Cole tackles one of the hardest ministry leadership calls: knowing when to keep developing a volunteer in their current role, and when it's time to help them move on. Drawing from a personal story, she walks through how to diagnose what's really going on before making a change.
You'll learn how to question yourself about keeping someone for their good versus your convenience, a way to tell a gifting problem from a discipleship one, and how to transition to a volunteer without losing the relationship.
TIMESTAMPS
01:04 - Story: navigating a volunteer mismatch
03:28 - Key principle: use ministry to build people
03:42 - Step 1: Diagnose the real problem
06:01 - Step 2: Recognize when to move someone on
07:54 - Step 3: Transition without losing connection
Resources mentioned:
Next Steps and Resources:
- Take the Quiz: Identify your growth gap with our Sticky Floor Quiz at www.femalechurchleaders.com.
- Join a Cohort: Be part of our next Closing the Leadership Gap cohort for guided coaching and monthly Q&A with Kadi. Visit www.closingtheleadershipgap.com to learn more.
- Stay Connected: Follow us on Instagram @femalechurchleaders for daily encouragement and leadership tools.
- Spread the Word: If you found this episode helpful, please follow, rate, and share the podcast to help us reach more female church leaders.
Tune in and get ready to lead with clarity, strength, and joy. Your calling matters, and we're here to support you every step of the way!
Welcome to the Female Church Leaders Podcast, a weekly resource for women who love God, love the church, and are called to lead. I'm your host, Katie Cole, church leader, author, and executive coach. After more than 30 years in full-time ministry, often as the only woman at the table, I understand how meaningful yet challenging your calling can be. That's why I created this podcast to remind you that you're not leading alone. Each week, I'll share practical tools, biblical insights, and honest encouragement for the real challenges female leaders face in ministry. So you can grow your skills, strengthen your faith, and lead with more confidence and joy without burning out or striving to prove yourself. We drop a new episode every Monday because Sunday is coming and you are gonna be ready for it. One of the hardest conversations you'll have as a ministry leader is telling a volunteer they are not a good fit for their current role, especially when they love your church, have a great heart, and genuinely want to serve. I remember facing this exact situation when I was leading a creative arts ministry. We had a young mom who desperately wanted to be our teen. She loved the idea of being on stage and she had a wonderful heart. But after working with her for a while, it was pretty clear that performing was not one of her strengths. And honestly, artistic and performance-based ministries can be some of the hardest places to navigate this. You want to encourage people to use their gifts, but there are certain skills those roles actually require. I was nervous about having this conversation. I mean, I was a volunteer leader myself at the time, and I didn't want her to feel rejected or unwanted, but I also knew we couldn't keep her in a role that wasn't a good fit. So I started by asking her, hey, how are things going? And she began telling me about her life as a young mom. Her schedule was full, she wanted to be a great mother, and she was fairly new to being a Christian and still figuring out what following Jesus looked like in her everyday life. Eventually, I asked her why she decided to join the creative arts team. And it turned out she had mostly only experienced our church on weekend services and thought being on stage looked like fun. She didn't really know what other opportunities were available to volunteer. So as we talked more about her relationship with God, her family, and what she hoped to experience at church, we started exploring some other possibilities. By the end of our conversation, she had decided to join a women's small group where childcare was available for her, to volunteer in her daughter's classroom instead during the first service, and then be able to attend the second service with the neighbors who had originally invited her to church. She was genuinely excited about this new rhythm. And we never even had to address her lack of fit on the creative arts team. When I checked in about a month later, she had connected actually with some other moms through serving in children's ministry, and they had invited her into her a mom small group that she was absolutely loving. Now, volunteer transitions don't always go that smoothly. This is kind of an ideal scenario. Sometimes you have to have a much more direct conversation. But that experience changed the way I approached moving volunteers out of roles that weren't working. I'd gone into that conversation worried about how to remove someone from my team, but what she actually needed was help finding her place in the church. And that brings us to a key leadership principle I hope shapes every decision we make. Just a reminder, we've talked about this before. We don't use people to build ministry. We use ministry to build people. So how do you know when to keep developing a volunteer in their current role and when it's time to help them move on? Well, we have three easy steps for you today. Number one, diagnose the real problem before making a move. Diagnose the real problem before making a move. When a volunteer isn't doing well, our first instinct is often to find them another place to serve. But before you start looking for a different role, figure out what's actually causing the problem. Is this a gifting issue? A scheduling problem? A lack of training? Or is there something in this person's character that needs to be developed? Those are very different leadership challenges and they require completely different leadership responses. Let's say, for example, someone consistently shows up late, doesn't follow through on their commitments, or struggles to work well with other people. Well, moving that person to another ministry won't solve that problem. You've simply handed another leader the same challenge you didn't want to address. This is where we need to remember that developing volunteers is part of our role as leaders, and it's definitely our role as disciple makers. Sometimes the most valuable thing we can do for someone is to help them learn to be defendable, to receive feedback, to communicate clearly, and to learn how to work through difficult relationships like a Jesus follower does. Those skills will serve them in all of their life, in their family, in their workplace, and every other ministry they'll be a part of for the rest of their life. Of course, make sure you've done your part first. Have you clearly communicated the expectations? Have you provided adequate training? Have you given them honest feedback and a reasonable opportunity to improve? And have you actually checked in with them and asked what's going on? Someone who consistently arrives late may need to grow in reliability. Or perhaps they're trying to get three small kids to church at 7 o'clock in the morning and a different service time would solve the problem. You won't know until you have the conversation. There is one important exception to this, of course. If there is serious misconduct, abuse, or safety concerns, they require appropriate action under your church's safeguarding and reporting procedures. Those situations should never be treated as ordinary placement problems or passed along to another ministry. But for every other everyday volunteer challenge, don't use reassignment to avoid the discipleship conversations you are actually responsible to have. Number two, recognize when keeping someone is no longer helpful for them to grow. Recognize when keeping someone is no longer helping them grow. Now, the opposite problem is keeping someone in a role long after we've realized it isn't working. Sometimes we do this because we're short on volunteers. That happens a lot. Sometimes we don't want to hurt someone's feelings, that happens an awful lot. And sometimes we've invested so much time trying to develop this person that we really want to be the leader who finally helps them succeed or at least get the return back on our investment. But our responsibility is to develop the person, not prove that we can make every volunteer placement work. A volunteer might have a wonderful heart and strong character, but lack the gifting required in a particular ministry. Or their season of life has changed since you first met them, and the schedule that once worked is creating unnecessary pressure on their family. Sometimes the ministry environment just isn't a good fit for them. Someone who struggles in a fast-paced, highly structured environment might absolutely flourish in a more relational one. Someone else might benefit from serving under a leader whose approach more supports their development. And occasionally, the best next step is a season away from formal volunteering altogether. Our job as the spiritual leader in this situation is to recognize when continuing in the current arrangement is no longer producing the kind of growth and fruitfulness we're hoping for. Now, here's an important question to ask yourself. Am I keeping this person in the role because it's good for them or because it's convenient for me? If the honest answer is that you need someone to fill the schedule, and that's why they're staying on the team, that's a ministry problem you need to solve, but in another way. It shouldn't become the volunteer's responsibility to remain someone they aren't thriving because you haven't stepped up in leadership fully yet. Number three, help them transition without losing their connection. Help them transition without losing their connection, especially to you. Once you've recognized that someone needs a different role, how you lead the transition matters just as much as the decision itself. So start with curiosity. Ask how they're experiencing the ministry. What are they enjoying? What's frustrating? How is their current schedule working? What do they sense God developing in their life? And really listen to their answers. You may discover something you didn't expect, just as I did with that young mom and our creative arts team. Sometimes the conversation will naturally reveal a better opportunity. But other times you'll need to be more direct about why the current role isn't working. Don't disguise an accountability issue as a gifting mismatch or make promises about another role you haven't figured out yet. But when possible, help them identify an appropriate next step rather than simply ending their current assignment. That might mean introducing them to another ministry leader, helping them explore a different schedule, connecting them with a small group, or encouraging them to take some time to grow before serving again. And please don't forget about your relationship with this person. One of the things I always want volunteers to understand is that where they serve doesn't determine their relationship with me. You can tell someone, just because you're not serving on my team anymore doesn't mean our relationship ends. We may not see each other every week or talk as often, but I still care about you and I always want to know how you're doing. Then make sure you follow through. And as you'll note, I kind of put the responsibility on the person. I will always want to know how you're doing versus, hey, I'll be following up with you, I'll be checking in on you. Now we do want to check in on them. In fact, a few weeks after the transition, you absolutely should reach out and see how they're doing. Did they connect with the new ministry leader? Have they started attending that small group yet? How are they feeling about this change? Don't just hand someone off, make sure they land well and have found their next place. It's easy to consider a transition successful because the person has left your team and the immediate problem is off your plate. But if they've quietly disconnected from church in the process, we have absolutely missed the point. The goal is to help them find a place where they can contribute meaningfully, develop their gifts, build relationships, and continue growing in their faith. That is the ideal scenario. Ephesians 4 tells us that Christ gave leaders to the church to equip his people for works of service so that the body of Christ may be built up. I love that picture of ministry leadership because our responsibility goes far beyond just filling volunteer positions. We're helping people grow into maturity and discover how God has gifted them to contribute to his church over their lifetime. Sometimes that means investing more deeply in someone who's struggling, and sometimes it means recognizing that the most fruitful next step for them is somewhere other than our ministry. Both require to put their development ahead of our immediate volunteer needs. So here's your action step for this week. Think about one volunteer in your team who may not be flourishing in their current role. Before you decide what needs to change, schedule a conversation to understand how they're experiencing their ministry and how their life is going in general. Go into that conversation curious rather than convinced you already know the answer. You may discover a training need, a discipleship opportunity, or a completely different place where that person could thrive. And remember, you don't have to solve everything in one conversation. Sometimes the most important first step is simply understanding what's really happening. And as you're thinking about developing the people you lead, don't forget to pay attention to your own leadership development. Sometimes the things slowing our growth are patterns we don't even recognize in ourselves. That's why we created the Free Sticky Floor quiz. It will help you identify some of the internal beliefs and leadership habits that may be holding you back so that you can take intentional steps toward growing beyond them. You can find it through the link in today's show notes. Thank you so much for the way you invest in the people God has entrusted to your leadership. The conversations we're talking about today aren't always easy, but they can become meaningful opportunities to help people discover their gifts, deepen their relationships, and take their next steps with God. Keep developing your volunteers as people, not just filling positions on the team. And we are here to cheer you on every step of the way. I'm so glad we got to spend this time together on the Female Church Leaders Podcast. I hope you're walking away encouraged, equipped, and reminded that your calling truly matters. To keep growing, join us for our next Closing the Leadership Gap cohort at ClosingThe Leadership Gap.com. It's a guided coaching experience, including live QA with me, designed to accelerate your leadership journey. If this podcast has been helpful to you, would you please take a moment to follow, rate, and share it? Your engagement helps the algorithms suggest our resources to female church leaders we haven't had a chance to meet yet. And don't forget to follow at female church leaders on Instagram for encouragement and leadership tools designed just for you. You can also follow my personal feed at Katie Cole spelled K A D I C O L E. Keep leading faithfully, keep growing your leadership gifts, and I'll see you next Monday because Sunday is coming and you are going to be ready for it.