The Female Church Leaders Podcast
The Female Church Leaders Podcast with Kadi Cole offers practical tools and biblical insight for women leading in the local church. Each week, Kadi shares real stories, leadership strategies, and spiritual encouragement to help you grow in confidence, sharpen your skills, and lead with clarity. Whether you’re on staff, volunteering, building a ministry, or stepping into new levels of leadership, you’ll find wisdom, hope, and a community of female church leaders who get it - and are cheering you on!
The Female Church Leaders Podcast
FCLP 43 | How Healthy Is Your Church Culture…Really?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this grounding leadership episode of the Female Church Leaders Podcast, Kadi Cole tackles a word we reach for too quickly: toxic. She walks through four distinct categories of church culture, from extraordinary to truly toxic, and the one principle that keeps you from mislabeling what you're actually experiencing.
You'll gain a clear way to assess both your immediate team and the wider culture around you, language for telling an unhealthy season apart from genuine toxicity, and a practical next step for seeing your environment more accurately.
TIMESTAMPS
00:41 - Healthy vs. unhealthy vs. toxic: why discernment matters
01:29 - Four categories of church culture
02:41 - Extraordinary culture
04:31 - Healthy culture
06:29 - Unhealthy culture
09:33 - Toxic culture
Email us at Info@KadiCole.com and tell us what has been helpful from the Female Church Leaders Podcast Season 1!
Next Steps and Resources:
- Take the Quiz: Identify your growth gap with our Sticky Floor Quiz at www.femalechurchleaders.com.
- Join a Cohort: Be part of our next Closing the Leadership Gap cohort for guided coaching and monthly Q&A with Kadi. Visit www.closingtheleadershipgap.com to learn more.
- Stay Connected: Follow us on Instagram @femalechurchleaders for daily encouragement and leadership tools.
- Spread the Word: If you found this episode helpful, please follow, rate, and share the podcast to help us reach more female church leaders.
Tune in and get ready to lead with clarity, strength, and joy. Your calling matters, and we're here to support you every step of the way!
Welcome to the Female Church Leaders Podcast, a weekly resource for women who love God, love the church, and are called to lead. I'm your host, Katie Cole, church leader, author, and executive coach. After more than 30 years in full-time ministry, often as the only woman at the table, I understand how meaningful yet challenging your calling can be. That's why I created this podcast to remind you that you're not leading alone. Each week, I'll share practical tools, biblical insights, and honest encouragement for the real challenges female leaders face in ministry. So you can grow your skills, strengthen your faith, and lead with more confidence and joy without burning out or striving to prove yourself. We drop a new episode every Monday because Sunday is coming and you are gonna be ready for it. We throw around words like healthy, unhealthy, and toxic pretty easily these days. A leader makes a decision we disagree with, a staff meeting gets tense, someone handles a conflict badly, and suddenly we're wondering, is this place toxic? Sometimes, well, sometimes the answer is yes. But often what we're experiencing is something much more ordinary. Imperfect people trying to follow Jesus and work together, sometimes doing that well, and sometimes not. Being able to tell the difference is an important leadership competency. As you grow in leadership, you need to be able to assess culture accurately, because your own experience is only one piece of the picture. So today I want to give you four categories of church cultures extraordinary, healthy, unhealthy, and toxic. Now, these aren't rigid boxes. A culture can fall between two and shift over time, but the distinctions matter, especially between healthy and unhealthy, and between unhealthy and actually toxic. Before we get into them, here's one principle I want you to keep in mind through this whole conversation. Church culture is really about a pattern. It's not about a singular person, an incident, or one bad experience. You can have a difficult sub-supervisor in an otherwise healthy church, or a wonderful supervisor protecting you from a larger unhealthy culture. Your department may be thriving while another is struggling, and you can personally be treated very well inside a culture that is actually harming people. Wise leaders learn to lift their eyes beyond their own day-to-day experience and ask, what is actually happening around me? Okay, the first kind of culture I want to talk about is what I call an extraordinary culture. These are the teams we all dream about. People are in the right seats and highly effective. There's a lot of trust, chemistry, alignment, and a whole lot of fun. They believe in the mission, bring out the best in each other. And when hard things happen, they handle them in ways that strengthen the team. When I was in my early 20s and a volunteer leader at my church, I was a part of two amazing teams. We loved one another deeply. We had so much fun leading together, and we saw God do some incredible things and we grew in our faith together. It was everything I saw in the Bible brought to life in my very own life. And because I was young and, you know, a bit naive, I just simply assumed this was how all ministry teams operated everywhere. But as life moved along and as I served on other teams, I quickly discovered, oh, apparently that experience is not simply automatic once you work in ministry with a whole bunch of other questions. Uh, cue the young adult crisis of faith moment, by the way. Even though I had to work through more realistic expectations, those early experiences gave me a picture of what was really possible and how rare and beautiful those seasons are. Having an extraordinary culture doesn't mean everything is perfect. There are still hard days, there's conflict, mistakes, and seasons where ministry is just, you know, kind of extra weighty. But what makes these cultures unusual is the level of trust and alignment underneath all of that and the way people respond when things get tough. If you are serving in an extraordinary culture right now, take my advice and cherish it. Learn from it, protect what makes it special, and don't assume something is wrong when every day isn't awesome. Now, extraordinary is wonderful, but if we're not careful, we can start to think that anything but extraordinary needs repair. Many faithful and fruitful churches have extraordinary seasons, but the majority of church teams are more likely in the second category, healthy cultures. Now, healthy cultures have good days and bad days. People disappoint each other, leaders make mistakes, you can have a difficult conversation and still worship in peace together afterwards. What makes the culture healthy is not high metrics or the absence of challenges. It's that overall you have spiritually and emotionally healthy people committed to working through the ups and downs together. Now, in a healthy church, most people are focused on Jesus and making disciples. We all know that is the number one goal. They're doing their best to live out the gospel and the biblical one-anothers that Jesus commands us, as bumpy as stumbly as those can be sometimes. But people can speak up. Leaders ask and receive feedback in a healthy way. Mistakes can be acknowledged and conflict is usually addressed. There is accountability, but there is also grace. And underneath it all, people are generally for each other. That matters because the ultimate goal of a great church isn't perfect productivity, it's unity. In John 17, as Jesus is preparing for the cross, he prays for his followers to be one as he and the Father are one. He connects their unity with the witness they will have in the world. Well, that gives us a very different measure of success than simply asking whether our church is growing, if teams hit their goals, or if we're maximizing everybody's potential. Those things can matter, but in the church, relationships, trust, respect, and unity are part of the mission itself, not as simply a byproduct, nor a tool to accomplish goals. They're the goal itself. A healthy church can have a bad year, a healthy staff can go through conflict, a healthy leader can make poor decisions. The question is, what happens next? Do we tell the truth? Do we own our part? Do we repair what was damaged? And do we remain for one another even when we disagree? Those are the marks of a healthy culture. The third type of culture is an unhealthy culture. Now, an unhealthy culture is where unhealthy behaviors, unhealthy people, or unhealthy leaders have gained enough influence that they're beginning to cause harm. Now, sometimes that drift is obvious, but often it happens slowly and quietly and usually behind the scenes. A church may have been healthy for years and then leadership changes. Maybe the new leaders avoid conflict at all cost. Maybe they tolerate poor performance or they play favorites. At first, the problems may stay isolated in certain teams, but if left unaddressed, unhealth tends to spread. People begin working around certain personalities instead of addressing problems honestly. Offenses get stuffed, trust begins to erode, communication becomes guarded, strong performers start overcompensating, teams become siloed, and healthy people start adapting themselves to unhealthy behavior just to keep things moving. That's why it can be hard to identify the moment a healthy culture becomes unhealthy. There may still be wonderful leaders, healthy departments, and people genuinely meeting Jesus and growing in their faith. Years ago, I took over a department that was really struggling. Team members were barely connected. We were spending far too much energy on minutia instead of ministry priorities. Several staff were underperforming and somehow completely okay with that fact about themselves. For almost a year, I worked to turn things around. We addressed structure, priorities, performance, and team relationships. We made progress, but I kept wondering why we couldn't gain real momentum. Many of the right things were finally in place, but we couldn't seem to break through into genuine, authentic health. Eventually, it came out that one of the top leaders had been having a secret affair. I wish I could tell you that my amazing gift of discernment kicked in and I had sniffed that out six months earlier. Nope. Unfortunately, discernment is not one of my top spiritual gifts. But it did teach me something I have never forgotten. We are made to be healthy. If you've addressed the obvious issues and a team still seems unable to move toward health, look deeper. There may be a person, relationship, behavior, or protected pattern carrying far more influence in the culture than you as the leader first realize. Now, that doesn't mean there's always secret sin hiding out there somewhere, but leaders have to learn to look beyond symptoms and discern what is shaping the system. And unhealthy cultures can recover. I've watched lots of teams and churches do it, but you usually can't lead your way out of an unhealthy culture using the same leadership behaviors that helped create it. Something significant has to change. Conflict may need to be addressed instead of avoided. Accountability may need to become consistent, and leaders probably need to change how they lead. The fourth and final type of culture is a toxic culture. This is where we cross an important line. This is a culture that is actively causing harm, and harmful behaviors are being used to maintain power by being normalized, protected, and even rewarded. In a toxic church culture, serious sin may be hidden to protect an influential leader or a ministry's reputation. Scripture or spiritual authority may be used to manipulate people. Questioning a leader may be treated as dishonoring or questioning God. People who speak up may be targeted, blamed, gaslit, or pushed out. You may see different rules for powerful people than for everybody else. Loyalty to a leader becomes more important than talking about the truth. Secrecy protects power. Fear keeps people compliant. Bullying, intimidation, favoritism, and scapegoating simply become acceptable parts of how the organization functions. These cultures are real and they've been around since biblical times. Scripture gives us examples of religious leaders misusing authority, protecting status, and placing burdens on people they themselves are not willing to carry. But I also think toxic cultures are less prevalent than our current social media algorithms sometimes make them seem. A leader disappointing you is not toxicity. Conflict is not being toxic. A church making a decision you disagree with is not a toxic culture. Even genuine organizational dysfunction is often unhealthy and inefficient, but it's not necessarily toxic and harmful to the people involved. There's a difference between being frustrating, annoying, or missing opportunities and actively harming people. And that distinction matters because toxic people and toxic cultures are no joke. I went through a season where there were pockets of toxicity connected to a particular leader I worked with. And it was incredibly difficult and painful every single day. What made it even more disorienting was that so much of the unhealthy behavior was hidden or minimized or simply overlooked by people at all levels of leadership, including the people that were being harmed by it. So if you're listening and realizing that some of what I've described feels uncomfortably familiar, I understand how complicated that can be. You may be carrying hurt, confusion, anger, or even questioning your own judgment because other people don't seem to acknowledge what you can see so clearly. You don't have to figure out what to do with that today. That's exactly what we're going to talk about next week in the final episode of this podcast for the season. We'll talk about when a difficult or unhealthy situation is something you can or should continue to lead through, and when it may be time to consider moving on to your next calling. But for today, I want to help you take the first step to begin to see your culture as clearly and accurately as you can. And that brings me to your action step for this week. I want you to assess the flower bed you are planted in. So look first at your immediate culture, your supervisor, your team, the people you work most closely with. Where would you place it? Is it extraordinary, healthy, unhealthy, toxic, or maybe somewhere in between two? Next, I want you to lift your leadership eyes and look at the whole garden. What patterns do you see across the larger church? What happens when people disagree or make mistakes? How is accountability handled? What gets rewarded? What gets tolerated, corrected, or even protected? Are people becoming more trusting and more unified or more guarded and more suspicious over time? The flower bed you work in every day matters, but the larger garden matters too, and they may not be equally healthy. So pay attention this week and try to see your culture as accurately and objectively as possible. What you see in your flower bed and the larger garden will give us the starting point for next week's conversation. But before we wrap up today, I have a personal request. This first season of the Female Church Leaders Podcast has been really a fun experiment. I wanted to see whether creating something specifically for women leading on the front lines of local churches could strengthen your leadership and ultimately strengthen the kingdom through the churches you're serving. So as we finish season one, I'm praying about what comes next, and I'd love to genuinely hear from you. Would you please take a minute and email me at info at katiecole.com, k a d-i-c-o-l-e.com, and tell me what has been helpful. Are there episodes you've shared or gone back to? What questions do you still have? What topics would you like me to address if we continue? And if there are things you think I should change or do differently, I would really love to hear that too. Leaders, after all, love feedback, and I would really love yours. I'll read every email that comes in and take your thoughts seriously. Your feedback will help me discern whether there should be another season, and if so, how to make it as useful as possible for female church leaders just like you. So thank you for spending this season with me, and thank you for continuing to grow in the wisdom and clarity your leadership requires. And I look forward to seeing you at our final episode next week. Remember, you are called, you're equipped, so keep learning to see clearly, lead wisely, and steward the influence God has entrusted to you. And we are here to cheer you on every step of the way. I'm so glad we got to spend this time together on the Female Church Leaders podcast. I hope you're walking away encouraged, equipped, and reminded that your calling truly matters. To keep growing, join us for our next Closing the Leadership Gap cohort at ClosingTheLeadershipGap.com. It's a guided coaching experience, including live QA with me, designed to accelerate your leadership journey. If this podcast has been helpful to you, would you please take a moment to follow, rate, and share it? Your engagement helps the algorithms suggest our resources to female church leaders we haven't had a chance to meet yet. And don't forget to follow at female church leaders on Instagram for encouragement and leadership tools designed just for you. You can also follow my personal feed at Katie Cole, spelled K A D I C O L E. Keep leading faithfully, keep growing your leadership gifts, and I'll see you next Monday because Sunday is coming and you are going to be ready for it.